Eric Elfstrom Joey McIntyre performs at Carnegie Corridor on January 14, 2023.
In the summertime of 1985, 12-year-old Joey McIntyre climbed up the creaky stairs of an outdated three-story brick constructing in Roxbury, Massachusetts, stood in the midst of a brilliant orange shag rug and, with out hesitation, sang “L.O.V.E.” by Frank Sinatra — a basic he had been singing round his home for so long as he might bear in mind.
Nearly 38 years later, McIntyre, now 50, walked onstage in entrance of a sold-out crowd at Carnegie Corridor in New York Metropolis and led the viewers on a joyful and emotional journey by way of his musical profession — which included performing Sinatra’s “L.O.V.E.” again like he had that day when he first auditioned in entrance of producer Maurice Starr to turn out to be the fifth and closing member of the boyband phenomenon New Kids on the Block.
“To say I’ve come a great distance appears like a loopy understatement,” says McIntyre, who spoke with PEOPLE the day after his debut efficiency at Carnegie Corridor on Jan. 14th. “I bear in mind being a child in Maurice’s lounge, singing that Sinatra track in entrance of them, probably not figuring out what it meant and the place life would take us from there. And now to be on stage at Carnegie all these years later, singing it to a room crammed with the love of associates, household and followers. I am simply actually grateful for all of it.”
Eric Elfstrom Joey McIntyre and his sister Carol Gallagher
On this night time, nevertheless, McIntyre actually understood what it meant to be there in that second. His setlist, a rollicking walk-down-memory-lane of solo hits, NKOTB favorites, requirements, present tunes and canopy songs, showcased his vary as an entertainer, musical virtuoso and eager collaborator.
“I did not need the whole night time to be an entire ‘that is my life’ factor however it’s exhausting to not try this when there are such a lot of necessary moments and individuals who have allowed me to get right here,” he says.
“I felt very current the whole night time. For one thing that was so monumental to me, I feel the one factor I might have requested for was to simply be current and never really feel just like the second was too huge,” says McIntyre.
Eric Elfstrom Joey McIntyre and Debbie Gibson
The star peppered his practically three-hour present with a number of shock visitor stars, like fellow ’90s teen idol Debbie Gibson (the pair reimagined her 1989 hit “Lost in Your Eyes” as a duet), co-stars from his time in Broadway and off-Broadway productions of Wicked, Waitress and Tick, Tick … Boom!, and members of his circle of relatives together with his sister Carol Gallagher and 15-year-old son Griffin, who performed piano because the duo sang McIntyre’s solo hit “Keep the Identical.”
Eric Elfstrom Joey McIntyre performs along with his son Griffin.
“It was a really proud Dad moment for me,” says McIntyre, who shares sons Griffin and Rhys, 13, and daughter Kira, 11, with his wife Barrett. “You know the way they are saying the one option to get to Carnegie Corridor is to observe, observe, observe? Nicely, that child practiced, practiced, practiced and it confirmed.”
One of many largest shock reveals of the night time got here when McIntyre introduced his NKOTB bandmate Donnie Wahlberg on stage to sing one other Sinatra basic for the Blockhead-filled viewers.
Eric Elfstrom NKOTB members Jonathan Knight, Joey McIntyre, Jordan Knight, Danny Wooden and Donnie Wahlberg
“It was extremely particular. I had the concept for Donnie to sing ‘One for My Child’ as a result of I knew it was one thing that was particular and completely different and necessary to me. To step up and sing a track like that, that is not essentially in his repertoire, at Carnegie Corridor was wonderful and simply a part of the spirit of that night time,” says McIntyre.
Following Wahlberg’s efficiency, McIntyre introduced all of the members of NKOTB — Wahlberg, Danny Wooden and brothers Jordan and Jonathan Knight — on stage to carry out their hits “You Received It (The Proper Stuff)”, “Please Do not Go Woman” and a private “Blissful Birthday” serenade to rejoice McIntyre’s fiftieth birthday in December.
“I attempted to tread calmly about asking them to be there as a result of we’re busy, 5 guys, and getting us on tour is a giant deal. For a one-off, it is not at all times simple. So I began with Donnie after which requested everybody else, they usually all mentioned sure,” says McIntyre, who carried out with NKOTB final summer time on the band’s Mixtape 2022 tour. “I feel the roof might need come off the hinges after they got here up. The place went nuts.”
“I could not have imagined doing an evening like this with out them there,” he says.
Eric Elfstrom New Youngsters on the Block at Carnegie Corridor
All through the efficiency, McIntyre says he made it a degree to permit himself to “indulge within the emotions of the night time” — even when that meant shedding just a few “completely happy tears” on stage.
“It was exhausting to not get emotional up there. There have been a few instances that I could not assist it, and I used to be squeezing the phrases out,” he says. “I used to be sort of anticipating it as a result of it is simply how I’m, however I needed to offer myself house to really feel it. Once you’re open and susceptible, while you’re round a lot love and in that protected place, it’s important to give your self permission to simply let stuff come up and share it with these round you.”
Eric Elfstrom Shoshana Bean and Joey McIntyre
As for what’s subsequent, McIntyre says his Carnegie efficiency felt “like a kickoff” for his plans to make his fiftieth yr additional particular.
“I have been saying to associates that I need to do 50 exhibits this yr, so 50 for 50,” says the star, though he admits that plans haven’t been finalized. “I am simply doing what I like to do, and taking it in the future at a time however I feel it’s going to all come collectively quickly.”
“It is good to have targets, and to work in direction of one thing that is necessary to you,” says McIntyre, who will subsequent star in Lifetime’s latest V.C. Andrews tale Dawn. “It sounds cliché however it’s concerning the journey. That is the present, to have the ability to create and work on one thing with individuals that you just love. I feel that is what we’re all in search of in life. I attempt to do not forget that it is not about, ‘hey, you probably did it.’ It is actually about, ‘hey, you are doing it!'”
By no means miss a narrative — join PEOPLE‘s free daily newsletter to remain up-to-date on the perfect of what PEOPLE has to supply, from juicy superstar information to driving human curiosity tales.